Retired Major General Gershon HaCohen told Srugim that the only viable governance for Gaza in the "day after" scenario involves the IDF maintaining control. He also warned against the notion of separating from Palestinians in the West Bank, emphasizing that Israel cannot defend itself under a two-state solution framework.
ON THE HOSTAGE DEAL AND THE IDF'S ROLE IN GAZA
Speaking amidst the ongoing hostage deal and military operation in Jenin, HaCohen stressed the importance of finalizing the deal to free hostages. He criticized opposition to the agreement, arguing it lacks public support. He urged leaders like Bezalel Smotrich and Itamar Ben-Gvir to adopt pragmatism, learning from Hezbollah's strategic flexibility.
HaCohen rejected the idea of ceding Gaza back to civilian settlement, calling it an unrealistic and divisive vision. He insisted that the true focus should be on the West Bank, which he sees as Israel's national future.
THE STRATEGIC IMPORTANCE OF THE WEST BANK
HaCohen underscored the West Bank's critical role in Israel's future, citing it as a solution to housing shortages and a means to sustain a growing population. He warned against territorial concessions tied to normalization with Saudi Arabia, which could include dividing Jerusalem, withdrawing from the Jordan Valley, and reducing Israel's borders to a line along Highway 6.
According to HaCohen, "Israel cannot defend itself under such conditions. The nation must understand that the West Bank is our national future, essential for security and strategic depth."
GAZA: NO GOVERNANCE WITHOUT THE IDF
Discussing Gaza's future, HaCohen dismissed the feasibility of a post-Hamas administration without direct Israeli military involvement. He argued that neither regional coalitions nor the Palestinian Authority could take on this role. "In the end, the IDF will have to remain in Gaza for decades to ensure stability," he stated.
LESSONS FROM THE CONFLICT
HaCohen described the IDF's achievements in Gaza as significant, highlighting the military's ability to penetrate heavily fortified areas and deliver a strong message of resilience. He argued that victory is not defined solely by war objectives but also by demonstrating the nation’s ability to endure prolonged conflict.
CRITICAL ROLE OF AREA C IN SECURITY
HaCohen emphasized that retaining control over Area C in the West Bank is vital for Israel's security. He outlined five strategic functions: protecting Jerusalem, securing the Jordan Valley as a buffer against radical Islam, maintaining control over the coastal plain, safeguarding southern Hebron hills for strategic depth, and ensuring safe transportation routes.
He concluded by stating, "With over half a million Jews already living in the area, the West Bank is essential for Israel’s survival and future growth."
Photo: Flash90